Skip to main content

Full text of "Raw Thought [pdf]"

See other formats

Believe you can change 

This post is part two of the series Raw Nerve . 

Carol Dweck was obsessed with failure. You know how some people just seem to succeed at everything they do, while others seem helpless, doomed to a life of 
constant failure? Dweck noticed that too — and she was determined to figure out why. So she began watching kids, trying to see if she could spot the difference 
between the two groups. 

In a 1978 study with Carol Diener, she gave kids various puzzles and recorded what they said as they tried to solve them. Very quickly, the helpless kids started 
blaming themselves: "I'm getting confused," one said; "I never did have a good rememory," another explained. 

But the puzzles kept coming — and they kept getting harder. "This isn't fun anymore," the kids cried. But still, there were more puzzles. 

The kids couldn't take it anymore. "I give up," they insisted. They started talking about other things, trying to take their mind off the onslaught of tricky puzzles. 
"There is a talent show this weekend, and I am going to be Shirley Temple," one girl said. Dweck just gave them even harder puzzles. 

Now the kids started getting silly, almost as if they could hide their failure by making it clear they weren't trying in the first place. Despite repeatedly being told it 
was incorrect, one boy just kept choosing brown as his answer, saying "Chocolate cake, chocolate cake."^ 

Maybe these results aren't surprising. If you've ever tried to play a board game with kids, you've probably seen them say all these things and more (Dweck 
appears to be missing the part where they pick up the game board and throw all the pieces on the floor, then run away screaming). 

But what shocked her — and changed the course of her career — was the behavior of the successful kids. "Everyone has a role model, someone who pointed the 
way at a critical moment in their lives," she later wrote. "These children were my role models. They obviously knew something I didn't and I was determined to 
figure it out."f 

Dweck, like many adults, had learned to hide her frustration and anger, to politely say "I'm not sure I want to play this anymore" instead of knocking over the 
board. She figured the successful kids would be the same — they'd have tactics for coping with failure instead of getting beaten down by it. 

But what she found was radically different. The successful kids didn't just live with failure, they loved it! When the going got tough, they didn't start blaming 
themselves; they licked their lips and said "I love a challenge." They'd say stuff like "The harder it gets the harder I need to try." 

Instead of complaining it wasn't fun when the puzzles got harder, they'd psych themselves up, saying "I've almost got it now" or "I did it before, I can do it again." 
One kid, upon being a given a really hard puzzle, one that was supposed to be obviously impossible to solve, just looked up at the experimenter with a smile and 
said, "You know, I was hoping this would be informative.''^ 

What was wrong with them? 

The difference, Dweck discovered, was one of mindset. Dweck had always thought "human qualities were carved in stone. You were smart or you weren't, and 
failure meant you weren't." That was why the helpless kids couldn't take it when they started failing. It just reminded them they sucked (they easily got confused, 
they had "a bad rememory"). Of course it wasn't fun anymore — why would it be fun to get constantly reminded you're a failure? No wonder they tried to change 
the subject. Dweck called this the "fixed mindset" — the belief that your abilities are fixed and that the world is just a series of tests that show you how good you 


The successful kids believed precisely the opposite: that everything came through effort and that the world was full of interesting challenges that could help you 
learn and grow. (Dweck called this the "growth mindset.") That's why they were so thrilled by the harder puzzles — the easier ones weren't any sort of challenge, 
there was nothing you could learn from them. But the really tough ones? Those were fascinating — a new skill to develop, a new problem to conquer. In later 
experiments, kids even asked to take puzzles home so they could work on them some more.^ 

It took a seventh-grader to explain it to her: "I think intelligence is something you have to work for... it isn't just given to you... Most kids, if they're not sure of an 
answer, will not raise their hand... But what I usually do is raise my hand, because if I'm wrong, then my mistake will be corrected. Or I will raise my hand and 
say... 'I don't get this. Can you help me?' Just by doing that I'm increasing my intelligence.'* 

In the fixed mindset, success comes from proving how great you are. Effort is a bad thing — if you have to try hard and ask questions, you obviously can't be very 
good. When you find something you can do well, you want to do it over and over, to show how good you are at it. 

In the growth mindset, success comes from growing. Effort is what it's all about — it's what makes you grow. When you get good at something, you put it aside 
and look for something harder so that you can keep growing. 

Fixed-mindset people feel smart when they don't make mistakes, growth-mindset people feel smart when they struggle with something for a long time and then 
finally figure it out. Fixies try to blame the world when things go bad, growthers look to see what they can change about themselves. Fixies are afraid to try hard 
— because if they fail, it means they're a failure. Growthers are afraid of not trying. 

As Dweck continued her research, she kept finding this difference in all sorts of places. In relationships, growth-mindset people looked for partners who would 
push them to be better, fixies just wanted someone who would put them on a pedestal (and got into terrible fights when they hit problems). Growther CEOs keep 
looking for new products and ways to improve, fixies cut research and tried to squeeze profits from old successes. Even in sports, growther athletes got better 
and better through constant practice, while fixies blamed their atrophying skills on everyone around them. 

But Dweck applied a growth mindset to the question of mindset — and discovered that your mindset could itself be changed. Even small interventions — like 
telling students they were doing well because they tried hard, rather than because they were smart — had huge effects. With more work, she could change totally 
fixed-mindset people into fervent growth-mindset ones. 

She herself changed, converting from a fervent fixed-mindsetter, always looking for excuses to prove how smart she was, to a growther, looking for new 
challenges. It was hard: "since I was taking more risks, I might look back over the day and see all the mistakes and setbacks. And feel miserable. [You feel like a 
zero]... you want to rush right out and rack up some high numbers." But she resisted the urge — and became a leading psychologist instead.^ 

The first step to getting better is believing you can get better. In her book, Mindset , Dweck explains how to start talking back to your fixed mindset. The fixed 
mindset says, "What if you fail? You'll be a failure." The growth mindset replies, "Most successful people had failures along the way."^ 

Now when I first heard about this work, I just thought: that's nice, but I already do all this. I believe fervently that intelligence can change and that talents can be 
learned. Indeed, I'd say I'm almost pathologically growth mindset. But even I began to notice there are some things I have a fixed mindset about. 

For example, I used to think I was introverted. Everyone had always told me that you were either an extroverted person or an introverted person. From a young 
age, I was quite shy and bookish, so it seemed obvious: I was an introvert. 

But as I've grown, I've found that's hardly the end of the story. I've started to get good at leading a conversation or cracking people up with a joke. I like telling 
stories at a party a story or buzzing about a room saying 'hi' to people. I get a rush from it! Sure, I'm still not the most party-oriented person I know, but I no longer 
think we fit into any neat introversion/extroversion buckets. 

Growth mindset has become a kind of safe word for my partner and I. Whenever we feel the other person getting defensive or refusing to try something because 
"I'm not any good at it", we say "Growth mindset!" and try to approach the problem as a chance to grow, rather than a test of our abilities. It's no longer scary, it's 
just another project to work on. 

Just like life itself. 

Next in this series: Look at yourself objectively 

Carol I. Diener and Carol S. Dweck, " An Analysis of Learned Helplessness: Continuous Changes in Performance, Strategy, and Achievement Cognitions 
Following Failure ," Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 36:5 (May 1 978), 451 a€"462. ■ 

Carol Dweck, Mindset: The New Psychology of Success (2007), 3. ■ 

Carol S. Dweck and Ellen L. Leggett, " A Social-Cognitive Approach to Motivation and Personality ," Psychological Review, 95:2 (1988), 256a€"273. ■ 

Claudia M. Mueller and Carol Dweck, " Praise for Intelligence Can Undermine Children's Motivation and Performance ," Journal of Personality and Social 
Psychology, 75:1 (July 1998), 33a€"52. ■ 

Mindset, 1 7. ■ 

Mindset, 225. ■ 

Carol Dweck, " How can you change from a fixed mindset to a growth mindset? ," ( visited 2012-08-18 ). ■ 

You should follow me on twitter here . 

August 18, 2012